Maths Invented or Discovered?
The PBS Ideas Channel has just released a new video which discusses whether maths is invented by humans, or whether it is discovered (ie whether it can be said to really exist). It’s an excellent 10 minute introduction to a pretty complicated topic – and certainly accessible for students:
For those interested in more detail – here are some of the basics (some of this information is simplified from the Stanford Encyclopedia which goes into far more detail). You can also see more discussion of the topic on this site here
The basic philosophical question in maths is ontological – ie concerned with existence. The Platonic school (named after Greek philosopher Plato) hold that mathematical objects can themselves be said to exist. Is there a “perfect circle” – in the realm of “ideas” upon which all circles on Earth are simply imitations? Is this circle independent of human thought? Does pi exist outside of human experience – and indeed space and time? The hard Platonists argue that mathematical structures themselves are physically real – and indeed that our universe may be a mathematical structure. Some other schools of mathematical philosphy include:
Logicism seeks to reduce all of mathematics to logical thought – if all mathematics is reducible to logic does that mean that mathematics is purely an intellectual exercise? 20th Century efforts by Bertrand Russell and others to reduce mathematics to logical statements have not enjoyed much success.
“According to intuitionism, mathematics is essentially an activity of construction. The natural numbers are mental constructions, the real numbers are mental constructions, proofs and theorems are mental constructions, mathematical meaning is a mental construction… Mathematical constructions are produced by the ideal mathematician, i.e., abstraction is made from contingent, physical limitations of the real life mathematician. But even the ideal mathematician remains a finite being. She can never complete an infinite construction, even though she can complete arbitrarily large finite initial parts of it.” (Paragraph from Stanford).
Mathematics therefore does not really exist in any physical sense – it is merely a construction of the mind.
“Fictionalism holds that mathematical theories are like fiction stories such as fairy tales and novels. Mathematical theories describe fictional entities, in the same way that literary fiction describes fictional characters. This position was first articulated in the introductory chapter of (Field 1989), and has in recent years been gaining in popularity.” (Paragraph from Stanford).
This line of thought tries to explain the amazing effectiveness of mathematics in describing the real world in a novel way – by denying that it does! The reality that we think is being described by mathematics is nothing more than fiction – there is an underlying reality which we know nothing about. Think about Nick Bostrom’s Computer Simulation argument – if we were within a computer simulation, then our mathematical laws may very well explain the computer code – but the real reality would be that which existed outside the computer.
Like this topic? Then you might also enjoy:
Is God a Mathematician? – A Michio Kaku video which looks at how mathematics can be used to model the universe.
Simulations -Traffic Jams and Asteroid Impacts – An example of the power of mathematics in modelling the real world